Psst! Want Some Chicken Pot Pie?

Posted: March 18th, 2010 | Author: | Filed under: Ken's Kicken' Chicken, Marketplace, Salem | Tags: , , , | 7 Comments »


Put on your trench coat and fedora. Drive to Salem on Route 114. If you’re sure you haven’t been followed, turn in between the Hess station and HMA Car Care. Turn left on Franklin, go to the end, and park. Proceed to Ken’s Kicken Chicken and score a large pie with stuffing…

Okay, so it’s not as clandestine as all that, but we were intrigued by the mainly word-of-mouth business Ken Rothwell of Rothwell’s Custom Catering has built up around his chicken pot pies.

Rothwell sold his Salem restaurant, A Taste of Thyme, four years ago and now runs the catering business out of a large industrial kitchen on Franklin Street. A few months ago, frustrated by the quality of available pre-packed chicken pies, his wife challenged him to come up with something better. Pretty soon, his friends were clamoring for them, and word spread from there.

Today, Rothwell is selling 1,000 pies per week out of the catering kitchen and has added a variety of high-quality prepared foods including 15 kinds of soup (the clam chowder is famous among those in the know), shepards’s pie, macaroni and cheese, meatloaf, and chicken broccoli ziti. Cold offerings such as Waldorf chicken salad (delicious), horseradish cheese spread, and hummus are also available, along with several desserts.

But the pies are the stars of the show, or perhaps we should say the heavyweights—the large pie with stuffing weighs five pounds. And we’re happy to report it lives up to the hype. The huge chunks of white-meat chicken are moist, the sauce is rich but not cloying, the vegetables are cooked perfectly (carrots and peas, tender but not mushy), and the stuffing is tasty with great texture. The crust puts it over the top—buttery and delicious.

We bought a large pie with stuffing, which is $16.95 and feeds four to six. Fresh pies take 35 minutes to bake and will keep for five days in the fridge. Frozen pies will keep for several months and take about an hour to bake. The pies are available in small ($8.95 with stuffing, feeds three), without veggies (chicken and stuffing only) and without stuffing (chicken and veggies only).

For now, the pies are not available in stores, and we recommend buying them during the week if you can. The lines are long on weekends, and they sometimes run out. Look for new offerings soon, including a chicken pie with cornbread topping and a buffalo chicken pie.

Ken’s Kicken’ Chicken
7 Franklin St, Salem
(978) 825-0200


7 Comments on “Psst! Want Some Chicken Pot Pie?”

  1. #1 Jon Heller said at 1:46 pm on March 18th, 2010:

    I work right up the road, with two people who know Ken, and so we were lucky enough to get some of these pies before he was even publicly selling them. Our whole office became obsessed though – I think we had 5 pies in the office freezer one day. Really good stuff!

  2. #2 JR said at 3:50 pm on March 18th, 2010:

    I know what you mean. I’m already jonesing for another one.

  3. #3 Geoff said at 10:54 pm on March 18th, 2010:

    You can’t overstate how good these pies are. It’s not possible.

  4. #4 Penny Cherubino said at 9:42 am on March 20th, 2010:

    One more reason to come North for a visit. We’ll have to bring a freezer cooler and have a local scout show us the way.

    I love good chicken pie and this one sound wonderful. Now explain the “stuffing” to those of us new to this masterpiece. Is it in the pie or on the side?

  5. #5 JR said at 6:17 pm on March 20th, 2010:

    Hi Penny–Scouts are available! The stuffing is in the pie. Right underneath the crust. It is soooo good!

  6. #6 Derek said at 9:19 pm on April 1st, 2010:

    All I have to say is these pies are incredible. I have never had a pie as good as one of these. I will be a return customer for life!

  7. #7 Jade said at 12:31 pm on October 24th, 2010:

    OH I’ve moved away and I’m so happy to have the recipe for the pie but I would really like the recipe for the stuffing to put in the pie….It’s the best…I still send anyone who’s coming for a visit to the store to pick up the pies. They are the best on earth.

Leave a Reply